- Aaron Arbon
Participated: 2016-2017
NCAA: SUNY-Cobbleskill (2017)
- Udhay Bal
Participated: 2018/19
NCAA: Mount St. Mary's (2019)
- Taylor Bratton
Participated: 2007-2009
NCAA: University of West Alabama (2009)
- Jahmal Brooks
Participated: 2008-2010
NCAA: Alabama State University (2010)
- Troy Christopher
Participated: 2011-2014
NCAA: Salem International University (2014)
- Shane Cole
Participated: 2005-2008
NCAA: Ohio University (2010)
- Jeff Dobos
Participated: 2007-2008
NCAA: Adrian College (2008)
- Canice Ejoh
Participated: 2014-2016
NCAA: Canisius College (2018)
- Trevor Hall
Participated: 2004-2005
NCAA: Salem International University (2005)
- Evan Kiser
Participated: 2016-2017
NCAA: Niagara University (2017)
- Jack Lamont
Participated: 2019-2022
NCAA: Bethany Lutheran College (2022)
- Brodie Mackay
Participated: 2016-2021
NCAA: Western Kentucky University (2021)
- Wes Markle
Participated: 2015-2018
NCAA: Piedmont International University Bruins (2018)
- Seamus McGrenere
Participated: 2020-2022
NCAA: Bethany Lutheran College (2022)
- Colin McLeod-Demers
Participated: 2020-22
NCAA: Illinois College (2022)
- Luke Melymick
Participated: 2009-2011
NCAA: Alabama State University (2011)
- Lee Ranta
Participated: 2004-2006
NCAA: Briarcliffe College (2006)
- Steven Sanders
Participated: 2014-2018
NCAA: University of Charleston Golden Eagles (2018)
- Matt Scanzano
Participated: 2013-2015
NCAA: Alma College (2016)
- Matt Sikorski
Participated: 2004-2005
NCAA: Wingate University (2005)
- Michael Ssemanda
Participated: 2015-2018
NCAA: Canisius College (2018)
- Chris Stewart
Participated: 2004-2007
NCAA: Bentley College (2007)
- Jonathon Thibodeau
Participated: 2013-2016
NCAA: University of West Alabama (2016)
- Troy Valeriano
Participated: 2011-2013
NCAA: St. Thomas University (2013)
- Cam Wilkie
Participated: 2011-2013
NCAA: Brown University (2013)
- Mark Wilush
Participated: 2011-2013
NCAA: University of Tampa (2013)
- Trevor Woodjetts
Participated: 2004-2006
NCAA: Tiffin University (2006)